Introduction:
In this case, the Court of Palermo examined a petition filed by U.S. applicants seeking recognition of Italian citizenship by descent from an Italian ancestor born in Sicily who emigrated to the United States. The applicants reconstructed their genealogical line across multiple generations, including minor descendants, and supported their claim with duly translated and apostilled civil registry documentation. The action was brought due to the impossibility of obtaining administrative recognition, as the case involved transmission of citizenship through the maternal line in the pre-Constitutional period.
Outcome:
The Court granted the application and declared that the applicants are Italian citizens from birth. It ordered the Ministry of the Interior, through the competent Civil Status Registrar, to proceed with all required registrations, transcriptions, and annotations in the civil status registers and to notify the relevant consular authorities. Legal costs were borne by the applicants.
Challenge:
The central issue concerned the transmission of citizenship through the maternal line prior to the entry into force of the Italian Constitution. Under the original framework of Law No. 555 of 1912, citizenship could not be transmitted by women, and Italian women could even lose citizenship automatically upon marriage to a foreign national. The Court addressed this issue in light of Constitutional Court judgments and Supreme Court case law, which have declared such provisions unconstitutional and clarified that their discriminatory effects persist over time unless judicially remedied.
Action:
The applicants demonstrated uninterrupted descent from the Italian ancestor and the absence of any voluntary renunciation of citizenship. The Court reaffirmed that the right to citizenship is permanent and can only be lost through explicit and voluntary renunciation, never by implication. It further confirmed that, in line with consolidated jurisprudence, the burden of proving any interruption in the transmission of citizenship lies with the State. In the absence of such proof, the applicants were entitled to recognition of Italian citizenship jure sanguinis from birth.
For the privacy of our clients, all names are fictional, and any identifying details in the judgements have been obscured.